16 Copycat Cookie Recipes That Are Surprisingly Wholesome — Eat This Not That

0
601

Ever craved the sweet taste of Girl Scout’s off-season biscuits or rushed to Target only to find your favorite Pepperidge Farm biscuits sold out? Now you can make the cookies you crave right at home. We’ve rounded up the best healthy copycat recipes of your favorite cookies with less fat and fewer carbohydrates than the store-bought versions. If you want to change something up for the holidays, add these instantly recognizable cookies to your baking sequence. Your cookies are sure to be on everyone’s lips. After you’ve had your fill of cookies, find out how to make your other favorite dishes in 45+ best healthy copycat restaurant recipes to try tonight.

Ambitious cuisine

These instantly recognizable, fudge-drizzled biscuits are a staple in any home! Get the same great taste of chocolate and shortbread with this copycat recipe! Made with just six ingredients, these cookies are made with a healthy combination of almond flour and dark chocolate for a lighter, looser, healthier taste.

Get the recipe from Ambitious Kitchen.

RELATED: Sign up for our newsletter for more healthy eating recipes and tips.

Healthy copycat Pepperidge Farm Chessman CookiesShutterstock

The holidays are here and these cookies are a classic for any dessert! These simple egg-free cookies only have four ingredients.

Get the recipe from Budget 101.

RELATED: 15 Best Christmas Cookie Recipes

Healthy copycat Pepperridge Farm Geneva biscuitsTop with cinnamon

When the pandemic broke out, Pepperidge Farm’s fan-favorite Geneva cookies stopped production and made us ask for them. Now you can make your own (healthier) version of it and satisfy your sweet tooth! With a healthy coating of dark chocolate and coconut or pecan toppings, you’ll forget you bought these at a store before.

Get the recipe from Top With Cinnamon.

RELATED: The 30 Worst Supermarket Cookies in America

Healthy imitation ginger snap cookiesAmy’s healthy baking

These healthy copycat ginger naps will have you saying “Oh Snap!” accept. Made from wholegrain flour, unsalted butter / coconut oil, molasses and stevia, this healthy variant of a cult classic will delight your palate.

Get the recipe from Amy’s Healthy Baking.

RELATED: 12 Healthy Smoothies That Taste Like Decadent Fall Desserts

Healthy Copycat Oatmeal CookiesGive me yummy

Get your full share of protein and nutrients with these healthy oat biscuits! Packed with honey, coconut oil, whole wheat flour, and a variety of raisins, walnuts, and cranberries, these cookies are so healthy they can even be eaten for breakfast.

Get the recipe from Gimme Delicious.

RELATED: 18 Cozy Sheet Pan Breakfast Recipes For Easy Weight Loss

Copycat Healthy Crumb Twix CookiesHayl’s kitchen

Crumbl is known for its huge, delicious biscuits that melt in your mouth. Bring that bakery into your kitchen with this healthy copycat recipe of Crumbl Twix biscuits. Made with oatmeal and protein powder, these cookies offer the same great taste and nutrients at the same time.

Get the recipe from Hayl’s Kitchen.

RELATED: The Best and Worst Cookies on Shelves in 2021 – Ranking List!

Copycat Healthy Store bought sugar cookiesDelicious toddler food

Sugar cookies are perfect for satisfying those with a sweet tooth. These are an egg-free version with the option to substitute healthier alternatives like wheat flour, coconut oil, and non-dairy milk.

Get the recipe from Yummy Toddler Food.

Copycat Healthy Milkbar Cornflake Marshmallow CookiesI am a baker

You will never see granola again when making these healthy copycat cornflake marshmallow cookies from Milkbar. Made from powdered milk and crunch cornflakes, it’s like breakfast – but healthier and in the form of a cookie.

Get the recipe from I Am Baker.

RELATED: The Most Iconic Desserts in America

Copycat Healthy Tates Bake Shop Chocolate Chip CookiesGluten-free recipe box

Transform your kitchen with this healthy copycat recipe for their famous chocolate chip cookies at Tates Bake Shop. Gluten-free, with the option to be dairy-free too, these cookies deliver the same great crunchiness as Tate’s chocolate chip cookies with no fat or carbohydrates.

Get the recipe from the gluten-free recipe box,

RELATED: We Tried 6 Chocolate Chip Cookies, and this is the best

Copycat healthy thin mint biscuitsBroma Bakery

With this healthy copycat recipe for thin mints, you are in direct competition with the Girl Scouts! These cookies are gluten-free, vegan, and made with dark chocolate and almond milk for the same mint goodness that melts in your mouth!

Get the recipe from Broma Bakery.

Copycat healthy monster biscuitsAmbitious cuisine

The only thing scary about these cookies is how healthy they actually are. Filled with oatmeal, natural peanut butter, and flour-free, these biscuits contain monster flavors with no carbohydrates.

Get the recipe from Ambitious Kitchen.

RELATED: 9 Most Expensive Desserts on Popular Fast Food Chains

Copy healthy oreo cookiesDesserts with benefits

Thinking that Oreos could be healthy might once have been a fantasy, but now it’s true. Combine your favorite milk with this recipe for healthy Oreos! These healthy copycat Oreos are sugar-free, gluten-free, dairy-free, and vegan! Delight your palate with this classic and immerse yourself in it.

Get the recipe from Desserts With Benefits.

RELATED: The Best and Worst Oreos in 2021 – Ranking List!

Copycat Healthy Nutter Shortbread CookiesVeggieKins blog

This vegan recipe consists of only three ingredients and is gluten and oil free. Not to mention, it replaces refined sugar with maple syrup.

Get the recipe from Veggiekin’s blog.

Copycat Healthy Lorna Doone Shortbread CookiesOmnivorous cookbook

Everyone loves a good shortbread biscuit, but nobody loves the extra fat and sugar that comes with it. This healthier version of Lorna Doone Shortbread Cookies is free from added sugar and surprisingly low in calories.

Get the recipe from Omnivore’s Cookbook.

RELATED: The Best Way to Keep Homemade Cookies Fresh Longer

Healthy Imitation Vanilla WafflesChocolate covered Katie

Vanilla waffles are a fan favorite. Whether you add them to your banana pudding or eat them straight out of the box, this healthy copycat recipe will ensure you never buy a box off the shelf again. These waffles are vegan and contain a lot of excess fat and sugar.

Get the chocolate-covered recipe from Katie.

Healthy copycat tagalongsChocolate covered Katie

Your friends will want to join you at every event after trying these copycat Tagalong cookies. Skip the trans fat that came with the original biscuits and bake them to your liking! The best part? They can be vegan, gluten-free, and soy-free!

Get the chocolate-covered recipe from Katie.

How to make more of your favorite candies:

76 best dessert recipes for weight loss

19 cheapest dessert recipes

The 15 Best Southern Dessert Recipes